Thursday, February 25, 2016

Fact Check - Is Obama Handing Guantanamo Bay Back To Cuba? By: Philip Ewing

Fact Check: Is Obama Handing Guantanamo Bay Back To Cuba? By: Philip Ewing
February 25, 2016

President Obama wants to finally make good on one of his signature
campaign promises: closing the detention facility at Guantanamo Bay,
Cuba. The Republican-controlled Congress is unlikely to go along, but
the debate has raised another question: If the prison closes, what would
happen to the naval base itself?

The Claim

Texas Sen. Ted Cruz warned about handing over the entire base in a
debate this month on CNN.

"One of the things ... I'm very concerned about is that Obama is
emptying Guantanamo. He is releasing terrorists that our soldiers bled
and died to capture. ... And I fear that by the end of this year,
President Obama plans to give the Guantanamo Navy Base back to Cuba,
which would be undermining U.S. national security interests profoundly,"
Cruz said. "I hope he doesn't do that. But it is consistent with his
pattern of the last seven years. I think it is a profound risk."

Cruz has repeated that "concern" in subsequent campaign appearances.
Another Republican presidential hopeful, Florida Sen. Marco Rubio, has
also "warned" audiences in rallies that Obama could give the base back
to Cuba.

"This makes no sense to me," Rubio said in Las Vegas, according to the
Washington Examiner. "We're not giving back an important naval base to
an anti-American communist dictatorship."

The Short Answer

No, say senior Obama administration officials — the president's proposal
covers only the detention center housed on Naval Station Guantanamo Bay.
The administration does not want to return the base itself to Cuba.

The Long Answer

The U.S. has leased Guantanamo Bay from Cuba since 1903, following the
American victory in the Spanish-American War. The land belongs to Cuba
but the original agreement — known as the Platt Amendment — gives the
United States "complete jurisdiction and control" over the base. A
subsequent agreement in 1934 gave the U.S. the use of Guantanamo "in
perpetuity," unless the U.S. either unilaterally abandons the base or
both the U.S. and Cuba agree to end the lease. Cuban leaders soured on
that deal following the Communist revolution and have steadily refused
to cash the annual lease payments from the U.S. Treasury of about $4,000.

Deputy National Security Adviser Ben Rhodes told reporters that when
Obama visits Cuba in March, he fully expects for President Raul Castro
and other top leaders to raise questions about Guantanamo's future.

"I'm sure that will be part of the discussion," Rhodes said. "They are
insistent our presence there is not legitimate, that the facility be
returned to them. But that is not on the table as part of our discussions."

Rhodes' briefing took place before the Pentagon released its proposal
for closing the Guantanamo prison. But another official reaffirmed that
position after the plan appeared. Pentagon Press Secretary Peter Cook
was asked specifically about the fate of the naval base and he said it
was its own separate issue.

"This plan covers the detention facilities at Guantanamo Bay," Cook
said. "There is no plan to change the status of the naval base at

The base's location in the Caribbean will keep it relevant for a very
long time, Navy officials say. In fact, its importance could only grow
once work is completed on the widening of the Panama Canal.

Broader, longer and deeper-draft cargo ships will be able to sail
through the canal carrying cargo to the U.S. and South America, and the
Navy wants to preserve a base from which it could protect those trade

Then-Chief of Naval Operations Adm. Jonathan Greenert described the
importance of the base when he visited in 2014.

"Naval Station Guantanamo Bay is going to be around for a long time,"
Greenert said. "Often, people think that if the [detention center]
leaves then the naval station will be shut down but that is not the case."

"We can repair and restock ships here and enable them to carry out the
mission of the Southern Command," he continued. "Also, at this very
location they have an air field, we have a natural deep port, we have
piers and we have room to grow. This base is really an essential part of
our future not only in the SOUTHCOM arena but broadly worldwide. This
base is strategically very important to the Navy."


CNN presidential debate, Feb. 17, 2016
"Rubio: Obama's Guantanamo plan 'makes no sense,' The Washington
Examiner, Feb. 23, 2016
"Naval Station Guantanamo Bay: History and Legal Issues Regarding Its
Lease Agreements," Congressional Research Services, Aug. 4, 2015
Press briefing by Deputy National Security Advisor Ben Rhodes, the White
House, Feb. 18, 2016
Press briefing by Defense Department press secretary Peter Cook, the
Pentagon, Feb. 23, 2016
Remarks by Adm. Jonathan Greenert, Guantanamo Bay, Aug. 27, 2014

Source: Fact Check: Is Obama Handing Guantanamo Bay Back To Cuba? | WAMU
88.5 - American University Radio -

No comments:

Post a Comment